Summing Up the Journey Through Earth Intelligence and Artificial Intelligence So Far (and springing forward)

I have been exploring Artificial Intelligence and Earth Intelligence this year. I want to give some practical examples of how Earth Intelligence can be used. As a first step, I have been developing a set of common terms. I have grouped the discussions below, simply, with a summary on every topic, so you can see the progression of the argument. It began like this…

Introduction to Earth Intelligence

I argued that the call of the Earth and the organic response to the call is intelligence. Another word for it is creation. It is not to be confused with “creativity.” Explorations of this call-and-response can be found in the following posts.

Artificial Intelligence and Creation 

A Short Grammar of Body, Mind and Earth in the Winter Woods


Augmenting Human Intelligence with Earth Intelligence

I extended call-and-response into an explanation of how it is possible (and desirable) to use the Earth to augment human intelligence. This partnership exceeds the capacities of robotic and information technologies put forward by champions of AI such as Elon Musk and Gary Kasparov and the concepts of “creativity” which prepare humans for machine thought. Do note, however, that this kind of intelligence is designed to create something other than self-driving cars. That’s rather the point.


Economic Viability, Environmental Sustainability and Elon Musk

Deep Thinking, Out Thought, Human Intelligence and the Earth

Poetry is Earth Intelligence (and an antidote to AI)

As an example of a form of this partnership, I offered poetry as one form of Earth Intelligence within humans. Although it has largely been replaced by artificial intelligences, its skills are still known and replicable. What’s more, it offers opportunities for resisting AI, whether lodged in humans, societies or machines. I will be picking up this theme later with arguments for considering farming as another form of this paying of attention.


Artificial Intelligence, Psssst, Over Here, I Have a Gift for You


Humans Think With Bodies Within Environments

I then opened up the notion of poetry as an environmental balance into understandings of humans as environments, focussed (as opposed to the common colonial notion of humans moving as independent actors through empty space. It’s time to set that to rest.) I developed this observation further, with notions that machines are focussed environments as well. However, their environments are profoundly different and are not interchangeable with human ones. I left it as an unstated given that such machine environments will profoundly change human life, in machine ways, or that this is happening. There is still, however, serendipity and the foundational principle of resistance.


Artificial Intelligence and You, Part 1


Social Environments Are Artificial Intelligences

In the next post, I extended the notion of environments into its mirror version: if social environments are actually relationships to humans within the Earth, Earth environments are also social. Environments are part of the human social group. The sign below is family.

Artificial Intelligence and You: Part 2


Choose Your Environment Carefully.

On that foundation, I offered the advice to be aware of how environments control people, and to what ends. Human choices matter, because they are the self, and the connections, a person has to weave a world with. I left the obvious conclusion unstated, that only a self with such connections can do the weaving; otherwise they are using the connections to weave something else.

Artificial Intelligence in the Wetlands


All Art is a Form of AI

To make sure I was clear, I pointed out that all humans are complicit, not just the members of elite social classes such as Elon Musk.

Artificial Intelligence 3: What is Intelligence


Environments Create the Artifice of Creative Response

I then brought the first thread back to its opening and tied it off with the observation that creation is part of the capacity of environments. I left it for readers to draw the conclusion that “creativity” is an art form made out of this force of creation and only able to actually create within the environment. In all other senses, it can only elaborate artifices and draw down the power of creation.

Artificial Intelligence 4: What is Artificial?


Old Tech Still Functions

To take the discussion into its second level, that of human interface with Earth, I then laid down the observation that the absence of this understanding in neo-colonial North American culture is cultural and racial only. With that observation, I was laying the foundation for an ongoing discussion of the limits of opposing understandings, such as wilderness or nature (to use neo-colonial jargon “the other” [sorry for the linguistic lapse, but I want to be clear]). I left (I hope) the subtext that cultural and racial history, however profound, is a bad reason for promoting the romantic myth of individual heroism, or for diminishing interactions with the Earth, body to body, by fitting them into frontier narratives of heroism. I used an ancient (and still living) non-narrative, non-linear form of technological interface as an invitation to consider the limitation of contemporary understandings.


Artificial Intelligence and Buffalo Eddy: Part 5 of a series


The World of the Umwelt

To support an entrance into the functional process of this technology, I reintroduced the understanding that environments are an active force. They do not work on us.

The Pheasants are Messing With You (and the Coyotes, Too)


The World is a Revolving Circular Space, Specifically Human

In other words, humans are part of the Earth’s processes — if humans work with the Earth’s processes. If they work against them, they are working against them. In both cases, human environments are artworks created in union with other natural forces. Deviations from that union lead to alienation. People will begin to pace like tigers in zoos. It is with this argument (centred on an image from Iceland [below]) that I linked the indigenous world with the world of AI. I left the connections unstated. It bears repeating that one reason for leaving the connections unstated is that human minds can follow them. Earth minds can follow them. AI is stumped. I left for further development the notion that the transformation of poetry into a populist art form in our time is part of the process of developing AI and making humans more harnessable by machines, whether a populist poetry is desirable for social ends or not (which it certainly is.) This is a big discussion, and one to look forward to later on, as we build a common vocabulary towards it.

The Human Landscape


The Ecosystem of Thought

In this post, I provided specific information on how the human-Earth interface works, with five levels of consciousness occurring at the same time. The loss of any one diminishes human consciousness by 20%. A sobering thought.

The Five Levels of Consciousness Meets the Starlings in the Poplars


Consciousness Crosses Elemental Boundaries

I then stated the obvious, that the role of consciousness is to cross elemental boundaries. I left it unstated that this is also the role of the sun: particles that take 100,000 years to leave the core of the sun, arrive at Earth a few minutes after escaping the sun’s gravity, and take on form by joining with matter. As Earth’s creatures, we embody this process. Also food for thought (and for a later post.)

Consciousness vs. Intelligence


Actualized Intelligence is Predatory

I then returned this foray into indigenous intelligence to the colonial interface, with observations on how individual, North American intelligence surgically removes parts of Earth Intelligence and replaces them with artifices. I left it unstated that this is an embodiment of the process of colonization that transformed this continent from an indigenous space of creation to an individualized space of creativity (and environmental death). These forces are not always in direct opposition with each other. They are, together, both the formative force behind human society and the source that tears it apart. One thing is foundational, though: the Earth is part of the social group.

Artificial Intelligence vs. Consciousness: the B Side of the Dance


Creativity is Independence from Unity

I closed this series of observations by noting that intelligence sustained by artifice alone is neither intelligent nor artifice, as it lacks presence and volume. As a fantasy, it creates powerful fantasies. It cannot, however, approach the Earth. It will always be at a remove.


Consciousness and Environment: Artificial Intelligence Put in Place

Canadian Poetry Conference in Kelowna on March 17


Elemental Energy

It is my experience as a person in close conversation with both the Earth and my ancestors within language, that the destructive dichotomy between creation and creativity, and the indigenous Earth-based technologies of manipulating it, still have strong force within the English language, that English is, in fact, an indigenous, environmental language, and that a common language for both working with the Earth and communicating this knowledge and its ways to others is still strong within the language. To move the discussion forward, my next step was to lay down, step by step, an outline of the dimensions of Environmental English, or Earth Language. My first word is a form of whirling energy called Orkan. It is the most elemental energy of all.

Speaking with the Earth 1: Orkan

Earth Energy

I then showed a changed state of this energy, called Ore, as a demonstration of how human society and consciousness can work as an elemental switch, in synch with elemental changes in the world.

Speaking As the Earth: Ore


My next step in unfolding the language of Earth Energy was to show the language that speaks for its very capacity to open, and offer, in the twinned terms “bright” and “breadth,” to which humans (and others) respond (as the Earth’s speech.)

The Earth’s Opening into Speech: Bright


I then introduced the form of energy which allows for a bright or breadth space to be crossed, and followed up with an observation of gapping energy at work while I was away for a week pruning an orchard in the Similkameen.


Speaking With the Earth: Minding the Gap


Magnolias and Plums in the Ice Storm: a Pruning Guide

The Energy of Breakage

For every crossing of a gap, there is an initial breakage, a falling energy with creates not only breadth, but flats and crossings. It propels human attention forwards by removing the sense of being held up by the earth. This word is placed here to extend the depth of the gapping energy introduced previously.

Fjall: The Setting Forth from English as a Colonial Language


Next, I introduced yet another dimension of bright energy: width. It is to flat space what breadth is to a line. It is, in other words, falling that has spread out the fall, whereas breadth is a fall propelled forward until it closes a gap. Width is thus open. Because I love them, I offered you some Icelandic reindeer, grazing.


Opening Your Thoughts Wide


Next, I opened wide energy into a term for its inhabitation. I left it as unstated that was I was describing was not “wild” in the common colonial or neo-colonial sense. After all, you can’t enter that space if you distance yourself from it. You will remain at a distance. (That might be valuable, but it does have a context.)

Entering the Wild


Flat and Float

I then approached the notion of flatness as the environment of width, to help remove traces of colonialism from wildness, and to show how the energy of landing, or being held up, which existed before the break of a fall, necessitating the crossing of a gap, remains after a fall. In this new dimension, however, the human sensation is projected into the landscape, and humans enter it. We are beginning to enter the realm of intention.


Flat Out Floating

Mind, Thought and Memory 

On the foundation of the translation of width into will described above, I then introduced the concept of wilderness as a form of minding, or memory. It has many dimensions.

The Mind of the Wilderness


Next, I opened up a discussion of consciousness of space-as-body into a discussion of the nature of will, experienced not as an isolated consciousness but as an embedded one. Questions like this are at the heart of human survival in the face of the AI threat. (I do not limit the notion of AI to machine intelligence, as should be clear by now.)

What is Will, Anyway?



I then introduced a new class of energies, energies of concentration, materialization and movement, with a discussion of the nature of run energy, as an extension of will. It is movement in place.  A river, a run, after all, stays where it is. It is in place. So is this energy. I left for a later discussion the link between this energy, petroglyph technology, tracking and reading.


Á, Flow and Run: The Ancestral Energies


Next, I discussed stopping-energy, an energy form akin to the breakage that propelled a fall into will. I discussed positive and negative forms of stopping, and ambiguous ones, such as the Christian iron cursing the ancient rock shine below, among the vineyards at the mouth of the Rhine Gorge. I did, however, lay down a theme to be picked up later, that negative forms of stoppage are nuclear compression technologies, deadly to human life.


Artificial Intelligence: Stopping the Run


On the foundation of stopping-energy, I introduced its positive form, the stand, as a demonstration of how an intervention into Earth’s creation can participate in it towards increase, if done within its bounds. It’s worth remembering at this point that this discussion, and this laying-down-of-language is a way of exploring those bonds and their bounds, where our ancestors found they could be broken to increase energy, and where not.


Every Plant Makes Its Stand


Public or Private

I thought it would be useful to show how these notions worked out within the dominant colonial motifs of Canadian society: the class-based delineations of public and private space. I had fun. I need that. Don’t we all.


Canadian Private and Public Gardening Rules in Indigenous Space and Culture


Indigenous Space

And then I went on a walkabout, to see what I could see. I saw a lot. I deepened my ability to read. It was profoundly anchoring. I met the wood ticks of springtime. I reaffirmed my respect.

Earth Mother in Secwepemc Country

The Golden Man of the Chasm

Earth Intelligence at Work in the Nicola


Easter With Kojoti

The Timeless World of the Ancient Thompson Valley

Our Mother’s Bones


And now we can continue, with the next opening of our language, ever-deeper into indigenous space. The next discussion will be about an extension of a watering and a run in wilderness in the form of minding called a “wander” or a “meander.” Talk to you then. Until then, mind the ones you’re with.

2 replies »

  1. I recognise that what you have offered here is a discourse of some length and complexity. Thank you. I will need to return to it often.
    Early within it I came across the sentence, “this intelligence is designed to create something other than self-driving cars”. Perhaps the time is coming when we will learn what it means to be human. It will come “just in time” as such things always do. The fairy-stories teach us that.


    • In putting together this summary (after reading Lindqvist’s “Terra Nullius”, I was struck more strongly than ever by the notion that the idea of self-driving humans is a colonial fantasy linked back to slavery. Sadly, some ideas aren’t really gone with the wind. Perhaps they can’t bear to be brought into the light, though.


      Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.